Call Now Free Rental Analysis
Choosing a Manager

Should I ask to speak with other owners they work with?

Short answer

Yes, ask to speak with other owners a property manager works with, and ask for one whose situation resembles yours and who has been through at least one tenant turnover. Expect the company to get the owner's permission first, which can take a few days. Ask the reference about specific events rather than general satisfaction, and treat a flat refusal with no alternative as a warning.

This guide answers
  • Should I ask to speak with other owners they work with?
  • How many owner references should I ask a property manager for?
  • What if the owner reference says something negative?
  • Can I ask to speak with a tenant the company manages instead?
Should I ask to speak with other owners they work with?

Yes. Ask to speak with another owner the company works with, and be specific about the kind of owner you want: someone with a house like yours, who has been a client long enough to have seen a tenant move out and a new one move in. A reference like that is the nearest thing to a year of experience with the company before you have signed anything.

Owners sometimes feel awkward asking, as if it implies distrust. It does not. Every serious business expects to be checked, and a company that manages people's houses and money should expect it more than most.

How to ask so you get a useful reference

The phrasing matters. "Can I talk to some of your clients?" gets you the company's happiest owner, who may have a condo downtown and a tenant who has never been late. Ask instead: "Could you connect me with an owner who has a single-family house in Keller or North Richland Hills, has been with you for a couple of years, and has been through a turnover?"

That request does two things. It gets you someone whose experience predicts yours, and it tells the company you know what a turnover involves. Most good companies will need to ask the owner's permission first, so allow a few days. Ask for the reference by email so the request and the response are on record.

What to ask the owner once you reach them

Do not ask whether they are happy. Everyone says yes. Ask about events.

  • "When your last tenant moved out, how long was the house empty, and what did the turnover cost?"
  • "Tell me about a repair that went above your approval limit. What did you receive, and how fast?"
  • "Have you ever had a late-paying tenant with them? What happened and how were you kept informed?"
  • "Is your monthly statement clear without a phone call?"
  • "Who do you deal with, and what happens when that person is out?"
  • "Has anything surprised you on a statement, and how was it resolved?"
  • "If you had to leave, what would the agreement make you pay?"

Then ask the question that gets the honest version: "What is the one thing you wish they did better?" A thoughtful answer tells you the owner is being candid about everything else too. The track record guide covers the numbers to request alongside the reference call.

How to read a delay, a condition or a refusal

A delay of a few days while the company asks permission is normal and, honestly, a good sign; it means the company protects its owners' privacy. A delay that stretches into weeks with excuses is not. A reference who turns out to be the manager's relative, or who has been a client for two months, is a reference in name only.

A flat refusal deserves a direct follow-up: "I understand. Is there another way I can verify your work?" A good company will offer a sample statement, an inspection report, independent reviews that describe specific events, and its license record. A company that refuses references and offers nothing else has told you how it expects to be judged, which is on its sales pitch.

Why some good companies limit references, and what to do about it

Some well-run companies are reluctant to hand out references, and not because they have something to hide. Owners who get called repeatedly stop agreeing to it. A company with many clients may rotate a small pool of willing owners, which means the reference is real but curated.

So treat a reference as one source among several rather than the deciding factor. Pair it with the independent reviews, where the company does not choose who speaks, and with the documents you asked for at the first meeting. If all three sources describe the same company, you can trust the picture. If the reference glows and the reviews describe something else, believe the reviews.

An example of what a good reference call sounds like

Say you reach an owner with a house in Fort Worth who has been with the company for three years. You ask about their last turnover. They tell you the tenant gave notice in spring, the company inspected and sent a photo report with a repair list and estimates within a week of move-out, the work took about two weeks, and the house was listed with new photos as soon as it was clean. They mention the deposit itemization went out on time and the tenant did not dispute it.

Then you ask what they wish the company did better, and they say the renewal conversation started a little later than they would have liked one year. That is an illustrative call, not a real one, but the shape is what you want: specific events, a timeline, a document trail and one honest criticism. A reference who cannot describe a single event is not a reference.

What the request tells the company about you

Asking for a reference does something useful beyond the call itself. It signals that you are an owner who reads statements, asks about events and expects documentation. Good companies like clients like that, because clear expectations on both sides make the relationship easier. Companies that prefer passive owners will be less enthusiastic, and their reaction to the request is itself information.

It also sets the tone for how you will communicate once you sign: in writing, with specifics. If you want to start that conversation with us, reach out and ask for a reference in the same breath. We expect it.

How Perpetual handles this

Perpetual Property Management provides owner references on request, with the owner's permission, and we try to match you with someone whose situation resembles yours: a similar house, in Keller, North Richland Hills or Fort Worth, who has been through a turnover with us. If a matching owner is not available right away, we tell you that and offer the alternatives in the meantime: a sample monthly statement, a redacted inspection report, our fee schedule in writing, our public license record and our independent reviews.

We are broker-owned and local, and I am the broker. What the reference will describe is the same service every owner gets: consistent screening criteria, documented inspections with photos, vetted vendors, Texas-compliant leases, monthly statements in the owner portal, and a written quote with every fee listed before anything is signed. Ask the reference the hard questions. That is what they are for.

The takeaway: Ask for an owner reference whose situation resembles yours, ask them about events rather than satisfaction, and treat the company's response to the request as part of the answer.

Questions owners ask

How many owner references should I ask a property manager for?

One good reference is usually enough if it is well matched to your situation and you ask about specific events. Two is better if the company manages different kinds of property, so you can hear from an owner whose house resembles yours. Asking for five or more is unlikely to be met, because most owners do not want repeated calls, and the extra calls rarely change the decision.

What if the owner reference says something negative?

Take it seriously but in proportion. A single criticism from an otherwise satisfied owner, such as a slow renewal conversation or a statement that needed a question, is normal and honest. A criticism that matches a pattern in the independent reviews, such as slow repairs or surprise charges, is a real finding. Ask the company about it directly and judge the answer on whether it is specific and whether anything changed.

Can I ask to speak with a tenant the company manages instead?

You can ask, but most companies will decline for privacy reasons, and a tenant is not in a position to tell you about statements, fees or owner communication. The closest substitute is calling the company's leasing line as a prospective tenant and noting how you are treated, and reading tenant reviews with an eye to repairs and communication. Those two checks give you the tenant's view without putting anyone on the spot.

Should I ask the reference how much they pay in fees?

You can, but the answer may not match your quote, since fees can vary by property, portfolio size and when the owner signed. The more useful question is whether the fees on their statements have matched the written quote they were given, and whether anything has appeared that they did not expect. That tells you about the company's honesty, which carries over to your agreement regardless of the numbers.

Property management in Keller, North Richland Hills and Fort Worth. How full-service management works in Tarrant County →

Keep reading

Related owner guides

Choosing a Manager

Checking a Property Manager's Track Record: Numbers and Owner References

A manager's track record is four things: public records, performance numbers, owner references and a test you run yourself. Here is what to request, how to read it and what to ask the other owners.

Choosing a Manager

How to Read Property Management Reviews: Owner vs. Tenant Complaints

A property manager's reviews are written by two groups with opposite interests. Some tenant complaints are proof the company is doing its job for you. Others are a warning. Here is how to tell them apart in ten minutes.

Choosing a Manager

What to See at the First Consultation: Sample Agreement, Statement and Plan

Before you pay a property manager anything, you should have seen a sample agreement, a sample owner statement and a written plan for your house. Here is what each should contain and how to read it.

Ready to see what your rental should earn?

Request a free rental analysis and get a clear picture of market rent, demand, and what professional management would look like for your property. No obligation.