Checking a Property Manager's Track Record: Numbers and Owner References

A property manager's track record is not their review score. It is a set of numbers you can request, a license record you can look up, a handful of owners you can call, and a test you can run yourself in twenty minutes. Most owners never do more than the first of those, which is why most owners choose on a sales conversation and find out what they bought a year later.

This guide gives you the full method: the performance numbers to ask for and how to read each one, how to spot a figure that has been defined into looking good, how to request owner references and what to ask them, the public checks, and the test that tells you how the company treats a tenant inquiry, which is the thing that fills your house.

Four sources, in the order to check them

Owners asking how to check a manager's track record are usually hoping for one website. There is not one, but there are four sources that together give a clear picture, and they are quick in this order:

1. Public records. The license, the broker of record and any disciplinary history, all searchable through the Texas Real Estate Commission.
2. Their own numbers. Vacancy, renewals, evictions, collections and staff tenure, requested in writing with definitions.
3. Owner references. Two or three current clients you can call, chosen with some say from you.
4. Your own test. An inquiry on one of their listings, a drive past a managed house, and a look at the listing quality.

None of the four takes long. All four together take an afternoon, and they will tell you more than any interview. How to verify a property manager's license and reputation in Texas covers the first step in detail; the rest of this guide is steps two through four.

The numbers to request, and how to read each one

Ask for these in writing, for the company's whole managed portfolio, over the most recent full year. A company that tracks its business can produce them; a company that cannot is telling you it does not measure itself.

• Average days vacant between tenants. The time from the previous tenant's move-out to the new tenant's move-in, including make-ready. This is the number that costs you the most, and it should include the make-ready, not just the marketing period.
• Renewal rate. The share of leases that ended in the year where the tenant renewed. High is good, provided rent kept pace with the market, so ask how renewals are priced.
• Eviction rate. Filings as a share of managed doors. Low points to good screening; zero over many doors is possible but worth a question about how they handle non-payment.
• Rent collected versus rent due. The share of scheduled rent actually collected in the year. It tells you whether screening and collections work.
• Staff tenure and portfolio churn. How long the people who will handle your house have been there, and how many owners left in the year. Churn on either side is where service quality shows first.

The internal version of these, the ones you should track for your own house, is in the numbers that tell you if your rental is performing.

How to spot a number that has been defined into looking good

Every figure above can be made flattering by changing what it counts, so ask for the definition with the number. The common moves:

• Days vacant measured from listing date rather than from move-out, which hides the make-ready and can cut the real figure in half.
• Days vacant measured to lease signing rather than to move-in, which hides the gap before the tenant actually starts paying.
• Renewal rate excluding tenants who were asked to leave, or counting a month-to-month rollover as a renewal.
• Eviction rate counting only completed evictions, not filings, or counting only one year when the prior year was bad.
• Collections as a share of rent billed after write-offs, rather than of rent due under the leases.

You do not need to catch every trick. Ask "how is this measured, from what date to what date?" for each number and listen for a precise answer. A manager who defines days vacant as move-out to move-in has nothing to hide and knows exactly what the number costs an owner, which is the mindset you want.

Owner references: how to ask and what to expect

Yes. A reference call with a current owner is the closest thing you have to a year of experience before signing, and a manager who serves owners well is glad to arrange it. Two things make the request useful rather than ceremonial. First, ask for owners whose situation resembles yours: one house, out of state, a duplex, a first-timer, whatever you are. Second, ask for a reference who has been with the company through at least one tenant turnover, because the turnover is where management is tested.

Expect some limits. Managers cannot hand out clients' phone numbers without permission, so the usual process is that the manager asks the owner first and then connects you, which can take a few days. That is reasonable. What is not reasonable is a flat refusal, "we don't do references," or a single reference who turns out to be a relative or a business partner. A refusal is a data point about how the company expects its clients feel. The full method for requesting a reference and reading a delay or refusal is in should I ask to speak with other owners they work with; a reference call is the private version of a review, and it is more reliable.

What to ask the reference, in ten minutes

Owners who get a reference on the phone often waste it on "are you happy with them?" Ask things the owner can only answer from experience:

• "How long was your house vacant at the last turnover, from the old tenant leaving to the new one moving in?"
• "When was the last time you had to call them about something, and how long until it was resolved?"
• "Have you ever disagreed with a repair charge or a statement line? What happened?"
• "Who is your day-to-day contact, and has that person changed since you signed?"
• "What did they do at the last renewal, and did you feel the rent recommendation was right?"
• "If you could change one thing about how they work, what would it be?"

The last question is the one that matters. Every owner has an answer, and an honest reference will give you one. If the answer is a small operational thing, that is normal. If it is "I never know what's happening with my house," you have what you came for. A broader interview structure is in a scorecard for interviewing property managers.

The public checks that take ten minutes

Before the reference calls, run the checks that require nobody's cooperation. Look up the company and the broker on the Texas Real Estate Commission license search and confirm the license is active, the broker named is the person you have been talking to or supervises them, and there is no disciplinary history you have not been told about. Search the company name with the words "complaint" and "lawsuit" and read what comes up with a skeptical eye, because tenant complaints about enforcement are often a sign of a manager doing the job.

Then read the reviews, but sort them: owner reviews tell you about statements, communication and vacancy; tenant reviews tell you about maintenance response and move-out handling, and a manager who enforces leases will always have some unhappy tenants. Our reviews page is open for the same scrutiny, and the Justin Brown page gives you the broker's name to look up.

The test you can run yourself

Numbers and references tell you what the company has done. A twenty-minute test tells you what it does today. Find one of the manager's current rental listings and inquire about it the way a tenant would: by the listed phone number or the listing site's contact form, in the evening or on a weekend if you can. Note how long the response takes, whether it answers your question and whether it moves you toward a showing. That is how your future tenants will be treated, and slow or indifferent responses are a vacancy you have not had yet.

While you are at it, look at the listing itself. Are the photos professional and taken after the make-ready? Is the description specific about the house, the schools and the terms, or is it a template? Then, if a managed house is near you, drive past it. The yard, the exterior and the general upkeep tell you how closely the company watches what it manages. If a manager's listing and a manager's house both look right, the numbers are probably right too. Hold any manager, including us, to that standard.

How Perpetual handles this

Ask us for the numbers and we will walk you through them with the definitions attached: days vacant measured from move-out to move-in, renewals, filings, rent collected against rent due, and who on the team has been here how long. We will not quote figures on a web page, because a number without its definition and its period is exactly the kind of thing this guide warns you about. We will also arrange reference calls with current owners whose situation resembles yours, with their permission, including owners who have been through a turnover with us.

Perpetual is broker-owned, I hold the license, and both are searchable on the Texas Real Estate Commission site. The company is local to Keller, North Richland Hills and Fort Worth, every fee is listed in a written quote before you sign, and owners see statements, invoices and inspection reports in the owner portal, which is where a track record becomes something you can check monthly rather than trust annually. Run the tenant inquiry test on one of our listings; then contact us and tell me how it went. The property management page covers the rest.

The takeaway: A track record is numbers with definitions, owners you can call and a test you run yourself, and a manager worth hiring will help you with all three.

Questions owners ask

Property management in Keller, North Richland Hills and Fort Worth. How full-service management works in Tarrant County →